BIG NUMBERS AIN'T THE ONLY THING

What good is a big follower count if you can't reach them?

Hi, I’m Seth and SOCIAL MEDIA ESCAPE CLUB is posting on Summer Fridays.

Carter Vail recently had 400 people pre-save a new song.

In a recent Instagram video, he shows how 1,072 unique users clicked through to the pre-save page.

Now, that’s a 37.3% conversion rate, and in the world of “getting anyone to do anything on the internet” that’s a fantastic rate.

The scary part though is that he’s got 211,000 followers, which means just 0.1% of his fans pre-saved his new track.

I’m using Carter Vail to illustrate that a huge following on Instagram doesn’t guarantee huge pre-save numbers or sales or people signing up for your thing.

But, I’ve worked with a client who had “just” 5,000 email subscribers, sent three emails, and sold over $3,000 in vinyl and shirts.

This is all about getting the right people to know what the fuck you’re doing, which is hard when you rely on third party platforms that limit your ability to reach your audience.

Like Rick Rubin says, “make cool things, show it to your friends.”

But it’s hard when those 200K friends are all on Instagram.

This also goes for who’s willing to pay and support your cool things.

Ira Glass lays it out pretty well in an interview with Vulture:

It’s just crazy to me that people are having a hard time earning money making something so many other people clearly want.

Well, part of the problem is that people aren’t paying for it, right?

Right. They’re accustomed to getting it for free.

That’s the hole in the business model.

Artists are having a hard time earning money making something so many people clearly want.

But most people ain’t paying for it.

A few are, though, right?

Do you know who?

Who bought your last album? Do you have their email? Can you let them know you’ve got a new record coming out?

Do you know who your top supporters are? Do you know who spent $1,000 in your store in the last three months?

Are your west coast fans aware of your upcoming west coast tour? Or did 70% of your social media fans miss that one post you made about it two weeks ago?

It won’t get any easier to reach your fans on social media, and all the time you spend building a following there means shit when over half of them never see your posts.

Take your power back.

Start an email list.
Send emails that entertain, with a few less BUY NOW buttons.
Update your website once in awhile.

IN CASE YOU MISSED IT:

Some things I’ve written since I started HEAVY METAL EMAIL back in 2021:

Own the direct connection to your audience, or else white knuckle the chaos of the daily social media shit show and hope you never lose access to your accounts.

Instead of freely giving Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk all your “exclusive” content (which they monetize, then turn around and charge you to reach your followers), publish the bulk of your work on your own website.

From SOCIAL MEDIA CAN'T BE YOUR LONE WAY TO REACH YOUR FANS

---

So if your posting on social media multiple times per week for just 5-10% of your fans to see, you should probably “repurpose your social media posts” and put them into a weekly email newsletter.

Weekly? YES.

I bet your fans would love to hear from you every week (which is why they followed you on socials, came to your show, and bought the record).

From CASSETTES & EMAIL MARKETING WILL OUTLIVE EVERY SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM

---

Imagine just sending an email once a week directly to your fans, and seeing those emails actually help you sell things.

Then think about how much time you could spend on your art, your music, your design studio if you didn’t have to feed the social media algorithm for hours every day.

From UNHOOK FROM SOCIAL MEDIA

I’m Seth Werkheiser and I want to help you connect with your fans directly with an email list.

I’ve been writing SOCIAL MEDIA ESCAPE CLUB weekly since 2021, and your support is appreciated.

• Become a paid subscriber at $6/mo, or $60 per year.

• Buy me a coffee via Ko-Fi, Venmo (@Seth-Werkheiser), Cash App ($ethwerkheiser), or PayPal - it’s iced coffee season!

• Support a band and buy an album from my Bandcamp Wishlist

Got a quick question? Shoot me an email: seth@closemondays.com